Skip to main content

«  View All Posts

Pros and Cons of Home Addition Contractors

September 5th, 2023 | 5 min read

By Michael Flory

pros and cons of home addition contractors sunroom with tables and chairs custom built michigan

As a homeowner with aspirations to expand your living space, the allure of a home addition is undoubtedly enticing. However, the journey from envisioning your dream addition to its actual realization is accompanied by numerous decisions and considerations.

Among these, the choice of hiring a home addition contractor stands as a pivotal crossroad that holds the power to shape the trajectory and outcome of your project. This decision is often fraught with uncertainties and the desire to balance expertise with cost-effectiveness.

At Custom Built, we understand the intricacies of this decision-making process. With over two decades of experience in the construction industry, we've witnessed firsthand the transformational impact a well-executed home addition can have on a residence and the lives of its inhabitants.

In this guide, we delve into the multifaceted world of home addition contractors, offering a balanced exploration of the advantages and potential drawbacks of enlisting their services:

8 Pros of Hiring Home Addition Contractors  

home addition with patio and outdoor living space yard custom built michigan

Home addition contractors bring a host of benefits to your remodeling project, offering expertise, resources, and peace of mind. Here are some compelling advantages to consider when deciding whether to hire a contractor for your home addition:

1. Expertise, Experience, and Efficiency

One of the primary advantages of hiring a home addition contractor is gaining access to their expertise and experience. These professionals have a deep understanding of construction, design, and project management, ensuring that your addition is executed with precision and attention to detail.

Additionally, contractors have a streamlined process for handling home additions, which can significantly speed up the project timeline. Their experience allows them to navigate potential challenges, manage resources efficiently, and ensure that the work progresses smoothly. This translates to a faster completion time compared to tackling the project on your own.

2. Project Management

Coordinating a home addition involves various tasks, such as obtaining permits, scheduling subcontractors, and managing materials. A contractor takes on the role of project manager, handling all these responsibilities and ensuring that everything is organized and on track.

3. Access to Skilled Subcontractors and Quality Workmanship

Contractors often work with a network of skilled subcontractors specializing in various trades. This ensures that each aspect of your home addition, from plumbing to electrical work, is handled by professionals with the necessary expertise.

Reputable contractors prioritize delivering high-quality workmanship. Their experience and dedication to their craft mean that your home addition will be built to last, meeting or exceeding industry standards.

4. Access to Resources

Contractors can access various resources, from building materials to tools and equipment. This can result in cost savings, as they can often secure materials at better prices than individual homeowners.

5. Liability Protection

Reputable contractors typically carry liability insurance and workers' compensation coverage. This protects you from financial liability in case of accidents or injuries that may occur during the project.

6. Compliance with Codes and Regulations

Building codes and regulations can be complex and vary by location. Contractors are well-versed in these requirements and ensure that your home addition meets all necessary codes, preventing potential issues down the line.

7. Stress Reduction

Undertaking a home addition can be overwhelming, especially if you lack experience in construction and project management. Hiring a contractor alleviates this stress, allowing you to focus on other aspects of your life while they handle the complexities of the project.

8. Value Addition

A well-executed home addition not only enhances your living space but also adds value to your property. Contractors understand the elements contributing to higher resale value and can guide you in making choices that maximize your investment.

9 Cons of Hiring Home Addition Contractors

home addition contractor installing drywall custom built lansing michigan

While home addition contractors offer a range of benefits, it's essential to be aware of the potential drawbacks of hiring their services. These cons can vary depending on the contractor's experience, your specific project, and your expectations. Here are some key considerations to remember:

1. Loss of Control

Hiring a contractor means relinquishing some degree of control over the project. While this can relieve those seeking to offload the stress of managing every detail, it might not sit well with homeowners who want to make every decision themselves. Sometimes, contractors may choose materials and even subcontractors without your direct input.

Most of the time, however, you will still make every design decision before and during your home remodel.

2. Limited Customization

Some contractors work within a framework of tried-and-true methods and designs to ensure efficiency and cost-effectiveness. This can limit your ability to customize the project to your exact specifications. If you have a unique vision that falls outside the contractor's usual practices, you might face resistance or additional costs.

In most cases, however, contractors and design-build firms like Custom Built are flexible and willing to build your remodel to exceed your design goals.

3. Scheduling Conflicts

Coordinating schedules with contractors, subcontractors, and other stakeholders can be challenging. Delays in one area can have a domino effect on the entire project timeline. Weather, unexpected issues, and other factors beyond your control can result in unforeseen delays, potentially extending the completion date.

4. Communication Challenges

Effective communication is crucial for a successful project. Misunderstandings or lack of clarity can lead to mistakes, changes, and additional costs. If your contractor doesn't prioritize communication or fails to address your concerns promptly, it can lead to frustration and dissatisfaction.

Additionally, subcontractors must be able to communicate with each other throughout a remodel. Sometimes, this communication can be challenging due to scheduling conflicts or even a lack of familiarity between each company.

5. Quality Control

While many contractors are committed to delivering quality work, not all maintain the same level of attention to detail. It's possible to encounter contractors prioritizing speed and completion over meticulous craftsmanship. This can result in subpar workmanship that may require additional fixes or repairs.

6. Hidden Costs

Some contractors may provide initial estimates that don't encompass all potential costs. Hidden fees, unexpected material expenses, or change orders can drive the final bill. It's crucial to thoroughly review contracts and estimates to ensure you know all potential costs.

7. Limited Oversight

Despite your best efforts, it can be challenging to keep close tabs on every aspect of the project when working with a contractor. This can create uncertainty about the quality of work being done, especially if you're not on-site to oversee every step.

8. Dependence on Availability

Contractors may be juggling multiple projects simultaneously, which could impact their availability to address your project's needs promptly. This can lead to delays in communication and decision-making.

9. Warranty Difficulties

Securing multiple warranties with a contractor can be challenging due to the interconnected nature of remodeling projects. Let's take repairing drywall as an example:

If you hire one contractor for drywall repair and another for painting, issues may arise if the repaired drywall develops problems later on. It can be challenging to pinpoint responsibility, leading to a warranty dispute.

Next Steps to Hiring a Home Addition Contractor

Reflecting on the journey of exploring the pros and cons of home addition contractors, it's clear that the decision to involve a professional in your project is a significant one. The considerations, trade-offs, and nuances highlighted throughout this guide underscore the complexity of this choice and the impact it can have on your project's success.

The wealth of information provided here is a valuable tool in your decision-making process.

Whether you're drawn to the expertise, efficiency, and experience that a reputable contractor offers, or you're enticed by the prospect of managing the project yourself to retain control and potentially reduce costs, your choice will ultimately align with your unique priorities and project goals.

For 15+ years, Custom Built has stood as a steadfast partner throughout this exploration, offering insights and perspectives to empower you as a homeowner. Our commitment to quality, transparency, and delivering exceptional results remains unwavering. Your journey toward realizing your home addition aspirations is a personal one, and our team is here to provide support, guidance, and expertise at every step.

luxury home remodeling services design build firm custom built lansing michigan

Now that you know the pros and cons to look out for in your home addition contractor options, let’s take a look at how much your project will cost and how to approach it with your design aspirations in mind:

Michael Flory

Michael brings over 2 decades of building and remodeling experience to his position as the Owner and Visionary of Custom Built. Michael’s passion to make an impact on the home building industry has led him to serve for over ten years at the local and state Home Builders Association, culminating as President of the HBA of Michigan in 2020.