Skip to main content

«  View All Posts

9 Signs That Your Home’s Insulation Isn’t Performing Well

February 19th, 2025 | 5 min read

By Aaron King

signs that your homes insulation isnt performing well living room area with arm chairs and fireplace custom built michigan

Is your home feeling drafty, uncomfortable, or expensive to heat and cool? Poor insulation could be the hidden culprit behind uneven temperatures, skyrocketing energy bills, and even moisture problems in your home. It’s a frustrating experience for homeowners who want their spaces to be cozy and efficient year-round.

We understand the importance of proper insulation in maintaining a comfortable and energy-efficient home. With years of experience helping Greater Lansing homeowners improve their living spaces, we know how to identify and address insulation issues effectively. Our goal is to help you spot the signs of underperforming insulation so you can take action and enjoy a home that’s as comfortable as it is cost-effective.

In this article, we’ll explore nine common signs that your insulation isn’t performing as it should, providing you with the knowledge to tackle these issues head-on and create a home environment you’ll love:

  1. Drafty Rooms
  2. Uneven Temperatures
  3. High Energy Bills
  4. Ice Dams on the Roof
  5. Cold Floors in Winter
  6. Hot Spots or Overheating in Summer
  7. Moisture Problems or Mold Growth
  8. Pest Infestations
  9. Old or Compressed Insulation

1. Drafty Rooms

signs that your homes insulation isnt performing well homeowner shivering with blanket on the couch custom built michigan

Feeling a chill in certain rooms? Drafts often indicate gaps in insulation or poorly sealed windows. In older homes, insulation can settle at the base of walls, leaving voids that let cold air seep in. To identify the issue:

  • Check Your Windows: Ensure they are fully closed and locked.
  • Inspect for Drafts: Cold walls or frost inside your home in winter are telltale signs.
  • Consider a Thermal Scan: Thermal photography can reveal insulation gaps and pinpoint problem areas.

2. Uneven Temperatures

signs that your homes insulation isnt performing well adjusting smart thermostat temperature custom built michigan

If some rooms are consistently warmer or colder than others, your insulation or ductwork may be to blame. Uneven heat distribution can occur when:

  • Heat ducts are closed, disconnected, or blocked.
  • Registers aren’t adjusted properly; closer registers to the furnace should be partially closed, while those farther away should remain fully open.
  • Sunrooms or large windows lack proper insulation or ventilation.

Additionally, drafty doors, windows, and even pet doors can make it hard to maintain a consistent indoor climate. To address this, check:

  • Weatherstripping: Ensure seals around windows and doors are intact.
  • Registers and Airflow: Open registers in drafty rooms and ensure all areas of the house receive proper heat or air conditioning flow.

Addressing these issues helps ensure consistent temperatures throughout your home.

3. High Energy Bills

signs that your homes insulation isnt performing well couple reviewing energy bills custom built michigan

Skyrocketing energy bills are a major red flag for underperforming insulation. Heat often escapes through the attic as warm air rises and exits through poorly insulated ceilings. Key areas to inspect include:

  • Attic Insulation: Look for missing, wet, or displaced insulation.
  • Animal Damage: Insulation can attract pests like rodents, which tear it apart to create nests.
  • Roof Snow Patterns: If snow melts unevenly on your roof, it could indicate heat loss through specific spots.

Regular inspections can help you catch these issues early and reduce energy costs.

4. Ice Dams on the Roof

signs that your homes insulation isnt performing well roof ice dams in winter custom built michigan

Major icicles forming on your roof edge are a clear sign of insulation problems. Heat escaping through the roof melts snow, which refreezes at the edges, creating dangerous ice dams. These can lead to:

  • Water leaks.
  • Structural damage.
  • Safety hazards from falling ice.

Proper attic insulation and ventilation can prevent ice dams and protect your home.

5. Cold Floors in Winter

signs that your homes insulation isnt performing well homeowner with slippers and rug custom built michigan

Cold floors, especially in homes with basements, are often caused by poorly insulated areas. Inspect the bond, the space between the top of your basement wall and your flooring. Proper insulation here prevents cold air from penetrating your living spaces. 

Here are a few ways you can reinforce your home and prevent cool floors during the winter:

  • Seal Crawlspace Vents: Close them during the winter to keep cold air out.
  • Insulate the Foundation: Ensure the bond and slab perimeter are properly insulated.
  • Check Basement Windows: Repair or replace drafty or leaking windows to prevent heat loss.

6. Hot Spots or Overheating in Summer

signs that your homes insulation isnt performing well couple overheating on couch in the summer custom built michigan

In the warmer months, underperforming insulation can make cooling difficult. If your air conditioner is running constantly but your home still feels hot, check for gaps or cracks in insulation. Effective insulation keeps cool air in and warm air out, making your home more comfortable year-round.

Let’s review how to address spring and summertime insulation issues:

  • Inspect the Attic: Ensure attic insulation is intact to prevent hot air infiltration.
  • Seal Gaps and Cracks: Use caulk or spray foam to close any air leaks.
  • Verify Ventilation: Make sure attic fans and vents are functioning properly to regulate temperature.

7. Moisture Problems or Mold Growth

signs that your homes insulation isnt performing well ceiling with moisture damage custom built michigan

Mold and moisture are not only signs of poor insulation but also serious health risks. Wet or poorly ventilated insulation can trap moisture, creating the perfect environment for mold. Address all moisture and mold issues using the following steps:

  • Check for Leaks: Inspect the roof, windows, and plumbing for sources of water intrusion.
  • Replace Wet Insulation: Remove and replace any insulation that shows signs of water damage.
  • Improve Ventilation: Ensure proper airflow to reduce humidity and prevent mold growth.

8. Pest Infestations

signs that your homes insulation isnt performing well wasp nest in attic space custom built michigan

Pests like bees, wasps, and rodents are drawn to cracks in siding and attic vents, where they can nest in insulation. Their activity can destroy insulation, leaving your home vulnerable to heat loss. Sealing gaps and inspecting insulation regularly can keep unwanted guests out.

  • Seal Entry Points: Use caulk or mesh screens to block gaps and cracks.
  • Inspect Attic Vents: Ensure they are covered with pest-proof screens.
  • Remove Nesting Materials: Clear out any insulation damaged by pests to restore effectiveness.

9. Old or Compressed Insulation

signs that your homes insulation isnt performing well remodeler removing old cellulose batts custom built michigan

Over time, insulation can settle or compress, reducing its effectiveness. Solutions include:

  • Adding Insulation: You don’t always need to remove old insulation; adding more can restore its effectiveness.
  • Spray Foam Systems: These non-invasive solutions can fill walls without requiring major renovations.

5 Common Types of Insulation for Your Home

Choosing the right insulation for your walls depends on your budget, energy efficiency goals, and the specific needs of your home. Here’s an overview of popular wall insulation options:

1. Fiberglass Insulation

This classic choice consists of pre-cut batts or loose-fill material. Fiberglass is cost-effective, non-combustible, and provides reliable thermal performance. It’s widely used in walls but requires careful installation to avoid gaps that reduce efficiency.

2. Cellulose Insulation

Made from recycled paper treated for fire resistance, cellulose insulation is an eco-friendly option. It’s often installed as blown-in material, conforming to wall cavities for good coverage. Cellulose provides excellent soundproofing and performs well in reducing heat transfer.

3. Spray Foam Insulation

Spray foam expands to fill gaps and cracks, creating a superior air barrier and excellent thermal resistance. It’s ideal for hard-to-reach areas and uneven surfaces. While it offers top-tier energy efficiency, it comes at a higher upfront cost compared to other materials.

4. Mineral Wool Insulation

Made from natural stone or recycled materials, mineral wool is dense and provides exceptional soundproofing and fire resistance. It’s available in batts or rigid panels, making it suitable for walls, especially where safety and noise reduction are priorities.

5. Reflective Insulation

Reflective insulation uses aluminum foil layers to reduce radiant heat transfer. While often used in attics, it can be effective in walls when paired with other materials in warm climates to combat heat gain.

Each type of insulation has unique benefits. For walls, consider your home’s climate, energy goals, and any special requirements like soundproofing or fire resistance. Consult an insulation expert to determine the best solution for your needs and maximize your home's comfort and efficiency.

Next Steps to Upgrading Your Home’s Insulation

Recognizing the signs of poor insulation—such as drafty rooms, high energy bills, or uneven temperatures—is essential for keeping your home comfortable and energy-efficient.

Addressing these issues promptly can reduce energy costs and improve your family’s living environment.

At Custom Built Design & Remodeling, we’re dedicated to helping Greater Lansing homeowners enhance their homes with expert solutions and quality craftsmanship.

If you’re experiencing any of the issues mentioned, contact us today for a professional insulation assessment. Together, we can ensure your home stays cozy in winter, cool in summer, and efficient all year long.

luxury home remodeling services design build firm custom built lansing michigan

Now that you know more about signs that your home’s insulation isn’t performing well, let’s take a look at how to insulate your windows in cold weather, ways to level up your home’s energy efficiency, and common wall insulation solutions:

Aaron King

Aaron has been in the building industry his entire life. He worked in his family’s housing business growing up in Dewitt, MI, and for nearly 40 years, built homes in the Mid-Michigan area. He has also worked with the Greater Lansing Home Builder’s Association since he was 18 years old.